Mr Soup and Salad's
Quest for the Best
Tomato Soup

Quest for Best Tomato Soup
Our Quest for the Best Tomato Soup page is a great place to start in understanding how the ingredients you include will affect your Tomato Soups:
Colour
Texture
Nutritional value
Taste
Depending on your aims and goals you can adjust the ingredients and, or, their quantities for different results.
Over time you can experiment and develop a variety of Tomato Soups to have up your culinary sleeve!

This will make approx. 2500ml of Tomato Soup | Total kcal 945
5 Servings | 189 kcal per serving
Tomato Soup - Ingredients
Let's take a look at the ingredients we are going to use in this version of Tomato Soup.
- Beef Tomato - 1 Large
- Vine Tomatoes - 6 Large
- Cherry Tomatoes - 14 Medium
- Carrot - 1 Medium
- Red Chilli (Mild) - 1 Medium
- Red Onion - 1 Medium
- Red Cabbage - 80g
- Red Bell Pepper - 1 Large
- Beetroot (Picked) -60g
- Red Lentils (Split) - 50g
- Fresh Garlic Cloves - 4 Medium
- Vegetable Stock Cubes - 2 Oxo
- Dried Herbs - Basil - 1 Teaspoon
- Dried Herbs - Rosemary - 1/2 a teaspoon
- Black Pepper (Gound) - 4 Pinches
- Sea Salt (Hymilayian) - 2 Pinches
- Chiil Flakes - 2 Pinches
- Olive Oil - Extra Virgin - 2 Tablespoons

Wash the Tomatoes, Red Cabbage and Red Bell Pepper.
Give the Red Split Lentils a good rinse.
Tomato Soup - Ingredients Prep
Prepare the ingredients as follows:
- Beef Tomato - Slice into 8
- Vine Tomatoes - Cut in Quarters
- Cherry Tomatoes - Leave Whole (helps retain flavour)
- Carrot - Chop or slice into small pieces
- Red Chilli (Mild) - Slice, remove seeds, rinse and finely chop
- Red Onion - Chop into small pieces.
- Red Cabbage - Peel of about 4 leaves, wash and dice
- Red Bell Pepper - Chop into 1cm to 2cm pieces
- Beetroot (Picked) - no prep
- Red Lentils (Split) - Rince well
- Fresh Garlic Cloves - Finely chop
- Vegetable Stock Cubes - Crumble and add approx. 800 ml of boiling water
- Dried Herbs - Basil - 1 Teaspoon
- Dried Herbs - Rosemary - 1/2 a teaspoon
- Black Pepper (Ground) - 4 Pinches
- Sea Salt (Himalayan) - 2 Pinches
- Chilli Flakes - 2 Pinches
- Olive Oil - Extra Virgin - 2 Tablespoons
Why Roast? Roasting will deepen the flavour of the roasted items in the soup so it can be well worth it, but is not essential.
It adds time and cost. Maybe 40 minutes extra time unless you use the roasting time to do other parts of the meal.
Cost will depend on your oven and if you generate your own electric, say via solar panels or not. But at say 30p per kWh the extra cost might be around 40p in electric plus small cost for hot water to wash the roasting dish.
Idea? Instead of roasting the approx. 1500g of items in this soup maybe fill the oven and roast 6000g of the items and then freeze spare?
Idea? Roast as same time as roasting other food you need to roast, i.e. batch roast.
If you are on a very tight financial or time budget or limited cooking resources skip the roasting. I would suggest add a bit more garlic and herbs to compensate for not roasting the tomatoes, bell pepper and onion.
See below about soaking the non roasted ingredients together to allow them to marinate while these items are roasting.

Place the tomatoes, red bell pepper and half the red onion in a large roasting dish, grind some black pepper and a very small about of Pink Himalayan salt over the prepared veg. Optionally sprinkle with 1/2 a teaspoon of ground garlic.
Skip the salt if you want to reduce your salt intake as the Vegetable Stock cubes are also likely to have a bit of salt in them.
Drizzle 2 tablespoons of Extra Virgin Olive Oil over the veg and mixed together. (1 tablespoon in you are trying to reduce fat intake)
Sprinkle 2 pinches of dried ground Basil and 2 pinches of dried ground Rosemary.
Mixed Well again and place in a preheated over at 180°C for 40 minutes.
Removed from oven and stir and mix half way through roasting.
Take care not to burn the ingredients, stir every 12 to 15 mins if necessary.

Lakeland Soup Maker
I am lucky to have a Lakeland Soup Maker that my lovely wife got me as a present. Sadly, I don't think Lakeland make this soup maker any longer but we will be writing a review of other soup makers.

First Stage - Part Fill (While Tomatoes are Roasting)
Put the Red Cabbage, the other half of the Red Onion, the Red Lentils, Beetroot, Carrot, the Chilli Flakes, Dried Basil (1 teaspoon), Dried Rosemary (1/2 teaspoon), Chilli Pepper (finely diced), 4 Garlic Cloves (finely chopped), 2 crumbled Veggie Oxo cubes and add the 800ml of boiling water and jiust leave to soak. (1 veggie stock cube is also fine).

Use Smooth Setting (30 mins)
Set the soup machine to the smooth setting which will cook the soup for 30 minutes.
Use the blend function to further smooth the after cooking if desired.
NOTE: If you don't have a Soup Maker place the whole mixture in a large saucepan, bring to the boil and then simmer for 30 minutes with the lid on. Then bend to desired texture once cooked. You may need to let it cool down a little depending on your blending device and then re-heat a bit before eating.

Finished Tomato Soup
Your should end up with around 2500ml of soup which is enough for 5 servings of 500ml each (approx 190 kcal per serving)

Bowl of Mr SAS Tomato Soup
A lovely bowl of Roast Tomato, Red Pepper and Red Onion Soup

Label & Store
Label your soup and date it.
I store my soup in a air tight (air sucked out) Pyrex storage container.
This will keep it fresh for around 2 days. Personally stored in the air tight container I have found this soup fine to eat 3 to 4 days if stored in a well cooled fridge. See below regarding the official guidance on fridge storeage times.
VARIATIONS & IDEAS
NOTES: Maybe add 15g of grated cheddar cheese on top for added flavour. This would add about 50 kcal to the the soup making a 500ml serving taking the total to 240 kcal.
I also like to add a leaf of fresh herb finely chopped from the garden, usually basil, fennel or mint.
Two slices of brown wholemeal bread would add about 175 kcal to the meal.
Toasted with thin spread Marmite dips nicely! The Marmite would add 10 to 20 kcal to the meal.
Or you could stir in 1/2 teaspoon of marmite into the soup to darken the colour and give it a tangy flavour.
In total this would make the meal or starter is around 435 kcal.
STORAGE GUIDANCE FOR THIS SOUP
Fridge:
Keep in the fridge for up to 48 hours once cooled and stored properly. The Food Standards Agency advises cooling cooked leftovers and putting them in the fridge within two hours, then eating leftovers within 48 hours or freezing them. Your fridge should ideally be between 0°C and 5°C.
Freezer:
Freeze as soon as possible once cooled. For best quality, use within about 2 to 3 months. FoodSafety.gov gives 2 to 3 months as the freezer quality guide for soups and stews, while the FSA notes that freezing acts like a “pause button”, but quality can reduce over time.
After defrosting:
Defrost in the fridge where possible and use within 24 hours once fully defrosted. Reheat until steaming hot throughout, and only reheat once.
Will an air-extracted Pyrex container extend fridge life?
An air-extracted or vacuum-style container can help reduce exposure to air. That may help with:
- Flavour retention
- Reduced fridge odours getting into the soup
- Less oxidation
- Better colour retention
- Less drying or freezer burn if frozen
Michigan State University Extension notes that reduced-oxygen packaging can reduce dehydration/freezer burn and help food keep its colour, texture and flavour longer. However, it also says vacuum packaging does not replace refrigeration or freezing and does not prevent spoilage.

Fresh Beef Tomato
Provides the main tomato base. A large beef tomato gives body, moisture and fresh tomato flavour.
35 kcal
Tomatoes tend to have a kcal per 100g of 18 to 22 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Tomatoes provide vitamin C, potassium, folate, vitamin K and lycopene. Vitamin C supports normal immune function and collagen formation. Potassium supports normal body function as part of a balanced diet. Lycopene is one of the tomato’s key red plant pigments.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Adds a deep tomato-red base. Gives fresh acidity, juiciness and a soft texture once cooked and blended.

Vine Tomatoes
These are the main volume of the soup. They bring freshness, natural sweetness and the recognisable tomato soup flavour.
200 kcal
Tomatoes tend to have a kcal per 100g of 18 to 22 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
A major source of the soup’s vitamin C, potassium, folate and tomato phytonutrients. They also add water and some fibre, helping the soup feel lighter but still satisfying.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Strengthens the red colour. Gives a fresh, slightly sweet and slightly sharp tomato flavour. Helps create a smooth soup base.

Vine Tomatoes
Add extra sweetness and brightness. Cherry tomatoes can lift the flavour compared with using only larger tomatoes.
45 kcal
Tomatoes tend to have a kcal per 100g of 18 to 22 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Contribute vitamin C, potassium, folate, vitamin K and lycopene. Their natural sugars help balance the acidity of the larger tomatoes.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Brightens the colour and flavour. Adds sweetness, gentle acidity and a fresher finish.

Carrot
Adds natural sweetness and helps round off the sharpness of the tomatoes.
25 kcal
Carrots are approx 41 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Carrots are rich in beta-carotene, which the body can convert to vitamin A. They also provide fibre, potassium and small amounts of vitamin K and vitamin C. Fibre supports healthy digestion.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Warms the red-orange colour. Gives gentle sweetness and helps thicken the soup slightly when blended.

Mild Chilli
Adds warmth without making the soup too hot. It makes the recipe feel more lively.
6 kcal
Chillis are approx 40 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Red chilli contributes vitamin C and plant compounds including capsaicin. In this quantity, the nutritional effect is small, but it adds flavour without many calories.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Enhances the red colour. Adds light heat and a fresher, sharper edge. Texture disappears once cooked and blended.

Red Onion
Builds the savoury base of the soup. Onion gives depth and helps the tomatoes taste less flat.
45 kcal
Red Onions are approx 40 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Provides fibre, vitamin C and small amounts of minerals. Onion also brings natural sugars that become sweeter as it cooks.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Adds purple-red colour at the start, though this blends into the final red soup. Gives savoury sweetness and depth. Softens into the background.

Red Cabbage
Makes the soup more unusual and increases the vegetable content. Adds depth and a slightly earthy note.
25 kcal
Red Cabbage are approx 31 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Red cabbage provides fibre, vitamin C, vitamin K, potassium and anthocyanin pigments. Fibre helps support healthy digestion, and vitamin C supports normal immune function.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Deepens the red-purple colour. Adds earthiness and a slightly cabbage-like background note. Helps make the soup thicker and more substantial.

Red Bell Pepper
Adds sweetness, colour and a softer vegetable flavour. Helps balance the acidity of the tomatoes.
45 kcal
Red Bell Peppers are approx 26 to 31 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Red pepper is a useful source of vitamin C and also provides vitamin A-related carotenoids, fibre and potassium. It adds a lot of flavour and colour for relatively few calories.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Makes the soup brighter and sweeter. Adds red-orange colour and a smooth, mellow vegetable taste when cooked.

Pickled Beetroot
Adds earthy sweetness and acidity. This is one of the ingredients that makes the soup distinctive.
40 kcal
Picked Beetroot Red Cabbage are approx 28 to 65 kcal per 100g. The Aldi brand here claims 45 kcal per 100g.
Nutrient Factors
Pickled beetroot contributes carbohydrate, small amounts of fibre, potassium, manganese and other minerals. It may also add salt and sugar depending on the brand or jar.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Strongly deepens the colour towards crimson or burgundy. Adds earthy sweetness and a tangy pickled note. Helps make the soup look richer.

Split Red Lentils
Turns the soup from a light tomato soup into a more filling meal soup. Naturally thickens the soup.
180 kcal
Split Red Lentils are approx 311 to 353 kcal per 100g The brand used here claims 318 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Red lentils add plant protein, fibre, complex carbohydrate, iron, folate, magnesium and potassium. This is one of the most important ingredients for fullness and nutrition.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Lightens the red slightly as they cook down, but thickens the soup well. Adds a mild earthy taste and creamy texture without cream.

Fresh Garlic Cloves
Adds savoury depth and a stronger homemade flavour. Four cloves gives the soup a clear garlic character.
18 kcal
Fresh Garlic approx 149 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Garlic contributes small amounts of manganese, vitamin B6 and other micronutrients. The amount is small, but it adds a lot of flavour for few calories.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Little effect on colour. Adds savoury sharpness when raw, becoming sweeter and softer when cooked. Blends smoothly into the soup.

Vegetable Stock
Provides seasoning and savoury background flavour. Helps pull the vegetable flavours together.
32 kcal
Oxo Vegetable Stock approx 256 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
based on OXO’s prepared stock figure. Main nutritional point is salt rather than vitamins. Two cubes can add a lot of salt, so added salt may not be needed.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Little effect on colour. Adds savoury depth and makes the soup taste fuller. Too much stock can make the soup taste salty.

Dried Basil
Adds a classic tomato-soup herb note. Basil works naturally with tomato.
3 kcal
Basil approx 251 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Used in this amount, basil is mainly for flavour, although dried herbs contain small amounts of minerals and plant compounds.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Small green flecks if not fully blended. Adds sweet, herbal, Mediterranean-style flavour.

Dried Rosemary
Adds a stronger woody herb note. Rosemary gives the soup a more rustic flavour.
2 kcal
Basil approx 331 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Nutritional contribution is small at this quantity, but dried rosemary contains small amounts of minerals and aromatic plant compounds.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Little colour effect. Adds a pine-like, savoury herb flavour. Use carefully because rosemary can dominate tomato soup.

Dried Garlic
Adds savoury depth and a stronger homemade flavour.
2 kcal
Basil approx 249 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Garlic contributes small amounts of manganese, vitamin B6 and other micronutrients. The amount is small, but it adds a lot of flavour for few calories.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Little effect on colour. Adds savoury sharpness when raw, becoming sweeter and softer when cooked. Blends smoothly into the soup.

Ground Black Pepper
Adds background warmth and seasoning. Helps lift the tomato flavour.
2 kcal
Black Pepper approx 255 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Nutritional contribution is tiny in this amount. Black pepper is mainly used for flavour.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Adds tiny dark specks. Gives gentle heat and a sharper finish. No real effect on thickness.

Himalayan Sea Salt
Sharpens the flavour and makes the soup taste more rounded.
0 kcal
Salt 0 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Salt provides sodium, but no calories. Because the stock cubes already contain salt, this should be used carefully.- Leave it out if you want to cut down on salt intake, won't affect the soup (I often don't add salt to cooking)
Colour, Flavour & Texture
No colour or texture effect. Makes flavours more noticeable, but too much can overpower the freshness.

Crushed Hot Chilli Flakes
Adds an extra layer of warmth on top of the fresh chilli.
2 kcal
Chilli Flakes approx 282 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
Very small nutritional contribution. Mainly used for heat and flavour.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
Adds small red flecks. Gives a warming finish and a little lingering heat. Add a few more if you want the soup more hot spicy in flavour.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Helps cook the vegetables and carry flavour. Adds richness and a smoother mouthfeel.
240 kcal
Extra Virgin Oil Oil approx 884 kcal per 100g However the cold pressed high quality oil used here claims 824 kcal per 100g
Nutrient Factors
This is the largest single calorie contributor in the soup. Olive oil is mostly fat, especially monounsaturated fat. It can fit well in a balanced diet, but the amount matters for calorie tracking.
Colour, Flavour & Texture
dds gloss and richness. Softens sharp flavours and gives a smoother, fuller texture.

Mr SAS Dessert - Greek Yogurt, Orange, Strawberry, Blueberry & Mixed Seeds
360 kcal
1/4 pot of Lidl Milbona 5% Fat Greek Yogurt
1 large Orange (nice and juicy)
2 Large ripe Strawberries
4 or 5 Blueburries
5g Morrisons Four Seed Mix
In my case the strawberrys and blueberries were home grown, fun and easy to grow!